bb tell tale heart video critiques

cartoon version:
I would say out of all of them this one would be my favorite because the way the story was told there was a lot more suspense. I also noticed that the whole video was depicted in images that told the story, and still made a lot more sense than the other videos. from an artistic viewpoint this video I think was very surreal, and that's the best part, makes it so much more interesting
animated version:
This version was definitely the spookiest especially that scene where the phsycotic guy was peeking through the old mans door. I realised a lot of the original story was cut out, extremely summarized, and there was hardly any talking from the voice of the narrator. all in all, this video seemed a lot more like a movie trailer.
Muppet version:
this one I thought was great, although you probably had to watch it a few times for it to actually make any sense, it was also quite summarized, and the words where completely different from the original text. Muppet told the story in third person.
this video had a pleasant twist, it was a much happier or fun version(as in, not dark and ominous), nice for a change.


note: I was not able to put the videos on even though I put it on html.